Photo Credit: Midia Research
The traditional structure of the World Wide Web is undergoing a radical “flattening” as AI platforms like ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini replace search engines as the default portals for internet access. This shift is not merely a change in user preference; it is a fundamental disruption of the digital value chain that threatens to dismantle the ad-based economy that has funded the internet for decades.
From Interactive Search to On-Site Consumption
Historically, the digital world relied on a process of discovery: users would search, click through to a website, and interact with content. This journey provided multiple opportunities for ad placements and exposure to new information. Social platforms began the process of “flattening” this experience by keeping engagement on-site, but AI takes this a step further.
Instead of directing users to external sources like Reddit or news sites, AI platforms now deliver hyper-personalized, on-site answers. Industry analysts suggest this could eventually extend to entertainment; a user might one day ask for a “new Beatles album” or a “Pirates of the Caribbean” sequel and receive an instantly generated, platform-exclusive product, bypassing the original creators and distributors entirely.
The 80% Click-Through Collapse
The financial impact of this shift is already becoming visible. A July study cited by The Guardian found that Google’s AI overviews are undercutting the very sites they summarize, leading to as much as an 80% drop in click-through rates for results appearing below the AI summary.
As web traffic plummet, ad revenue—the lifeblood of the free internet—is expected to follow. This creates an “odd conundrum” regarding trust. While MIDiA’s consumer surveys show users turn to AI for tasks and information, they often acknowledge its inaccuracies. Despite this deteriorating environment of reliability, the convenience of AI is successfully outcompeting traditional search.
The Rise of the Digital Fortress
To defend against redundancy, the architecture of the online world is shifting toward “closed-border” systems. Entities like The Economist, Netflix, and Substack are opting for subscription-only models to protect their content from being duplicated or summarized by AI.
This transition suggests a future where the internet is split into two tiers: a “free tier” consisting of user-generated memes and marketing samples, and a “protected tier” where high-value, reliable content sits behind paywalls. As walls go up, the very data AI needs for training will become increasingly scarce, forcing marketers and publishers to adapt to a world where the “open web” is rapidly disappearing.
About the Author
