Photo by Szabó Viktor | Pexels
The landscape of the music industry is shifting once again as a decade-long partnership comes to an end. On December 17, 2025, YouTube announced that it will officially stop providing streaming data to Billboard for its US charts. This decision marks a significant divorce between the world’s largest video platform and the industry’s most recognized record of success, signaling a deep philosophical divide over how we measure musical popularity in the digital age.
A Disagreement Over Data Weighting
The core of the conflict lies in a technical but impactful formula: how much a “free” stream is worth compared to a “paid” one. On December 16, Billboard announced a new methodology to narrow the weighting gap. Under the new rules, 1,000 paid streams equal one album unit, while it takes 2,500 ad-supported streams to reach that same milestone. While this is an improvement from the previous 1:3 ratio, YouTube’s Global Head of Music, Lyor Cohen, argues it still misses the mark.
Cohen believes the current system is outdated, stating that it “ignores the massive engagement from fans who don’t have a subscription.” From YouTube’s perspective, a play is a play, regardless of whether the listener is a paying subscriber or an ad-supported user. By favoring paid tiers, YouTube argues that the charts reflect financial value rather than true cultural impact.
Revenue vs. Representation
This debate isn’t new. Industry veterans like Jimmy Iovine have long argued that paid subscribers should be “advantaged” to help grow the industry’s revenue. Indeed, 2024 data shows that paid subscriptions contributed over $11 billion to the US industry, while ad-supported revenue actually saw a slight decline.
However, YouTube maintains that “every fan matters.” By exiting the Billboard partnership on January 16, 2026, YouTube is choosing to prioritize what they call “equitable representation.” For genres like Latin, hip-hop, and electronic music—which traditionally see massive engagement on free platforms—this change could significantly alter their visibility on the traditional Billboard 200 and Hot 100.
As the new Billboard methodology takes effect on January 17, 2026, music fans will notice a major component missing from the charts. While Billboard will continue to track the industry through other data providers, YouTube is encouraging fans to visit their own dedicated charts to see a raw representation of what the world is watching and hearing. This split serves as a stark reminder that in the modern era, the definition of a “hit” depends entirely on who is doing the counting.
About the Author
