The Heart of the Matter: Confusion in the Marketplace
Since its founding in 1988, the Los Angeles-based brand has used the name Chrome Hearts for everything from jewelry to clothing, building an iconic status with a strong connection to the music industry through collaborations with artists like The Rolling Stones, Drake, and Rihanna. According to the lawsuit, Neil Young’s new band is causing confusion among consumers who might mistakenly believe the fashion brand has sponsored or partnered with the singer. The company cites instances of apparel vendors already assuming a connection, proving that “the likelihood of confusion is not merely hypothetical.” This legal argument highlights a key principle of trademark law: it’s not about who used the name first, but whether its use on similar goods or services is likely to mislead consumers.
A Clash of Titans
While Neil Young’s original band, Crazy Horse, is well-known, his new group, The Chrome Hearts, which debuted last September and released an album this summer, has a much different name. The fashion brand says it reached out to Young’s team to “respectfully request” that he stop using the name, but when those efforts failed, they were “forced to bring this complaint.” The company is now seeking a legal injunction to immediately stop Young from using the name, as well as unspecified damages. Given the brand’s history of intentional promotion within the music scene—and the fact that band merchandise like t-shirts falls squarely into the same category as apparel—this case may be a tricky one for Young to navigate.
This lawsuit serves as a powerful reminder of the value of intellectual property, even in seemingly unrelated industries. As the legal teams for both sides prepare for a fight, the case will ultimately decide whether two iconic names can coexist, or if one must change to protect the brand identity of the other.
Read the Billboard article.
About the Author
